responsibility for ensuring compliance
The law (§ 5 para. 1 and 2 GewHG) states that the responsibility for ensuring the provision of services will begin on January 1, 2027. This responsibility means that support services such as shelters (women's shelters) and specialist counseling centers must be offered and available in sufficient numbers and in an appropriate geographical distribution.
At the same time, however, the legal entitlement to this support was negotiated and dated January 1, 2032, given that the aid system must first be gradually established and expanded. Conversely, this means that, due to the lack of an entitlement, no rights can yet be derived for those affected, but the states also cannot simply "rest" until 2032.
Therefore, from 2027 onwards, a distribution of value added tax between the federal government and the states is planned (§ 1 para. 2 Fiscal Equalization Act), which is intended to provide the states with more funds for this purpose.
Lack of or unsystematic synchronization of individual regulations
Sections 4(2) and (4) of the Trade and Commerce Act (GewHG) stipulate that victims of violence can contact institutions under the GewHG and specify the procedure to follow when children use the support system. These provisions have already entered into force, but correspond to the legal entitlement under Section 3, which will not come into force until 2032. Therefore, they are currently ineffective.
The same applies to the first contacted institution when providing support for contacting other institutions pursuant to Section 4 Paragraph 3, which are addressed to institutions "under this law", i.e. the Violence Assistance Act.
Facilities operating under the German Act on the Protection of Victims of Violence (GewHG) are defined in Section 2, Paragraph 4 of the GewHG. All tasks that these facilities are intended to fulfill, or requirements that apply to them, only come into effect once they are considered "facilities under the Act." They can only become such once the state implementing laws have established the parameters (according to Section 6 of the GewHG), once the rules for provider accreditation have been determined, and once the necessity of a facility has been established according to the development plan. Only then, if a provider has received accreditation and operates a facility that meets the requirements and is deemed necessary, does the facility qualify as a facility under the Act on the Protection of Victims of Violence.
While the facilities are required to guarantee compliance with the regulations by February 28, 2027 (§ 6 para. 6 sentence 3 GewHG), adherence to this deadline depends on three factors: definition by state implementing laws, implementation of the initial analysis and development planning as defined in § 8 GewHG (before 2027 with a reporting deadline of June 30, 2029), and the resulting necessity within the framework of ensuring compliance with the corresponding entitlement to funding under § 5 para. 3 GewHG.
Significance of the time periods of the article law for a reliable support system in cases of gender-based and domestic violence
Timeframe until the end of 2026
Although the Violence Assistance Act has been in effect since February 28, 2025, the current funding framework remains unchanged due to the lack of federal financial participation. Furthermore, no state implementing legislation based on the Violence Assistance Act exists yet that offers an alternative funding model. State laws such as the Thuringian Equal Opportunities Promotion Act or Section 23 of the Schleswig-Holstein Fiscal Equalization Act (allocations for the support of women's shelters and women's counseling centers) have been in place for some time and are not affected by this change.
Time period 2027 to 2029
On January 1, 2027, the states will be obligated to ensure a reliable support system. At the same time, they will receive a share of the value-added tax revenue from the federal government through the fiscal equalization system. However, since both elements are aimed at implementing the legal entitlement to protection and counselling from 2032 onwards, the existing financing, which consists of various components such as municipal funding and social welfare entitlements, will not be replaced.
Time period 2030-2031
Due to the postponement of the originally scheduled start of the legal entitlement to VAT in 2030, these two years constitute a further interim period. Before 2030, all federal states are required to submit the report on the initial analysis and development plan stipulated in Section 8 Paragraph 3 Sentence 2 of the Trade and Commerce Act (GewHG). A further – higher – tranche of VAT relief will be linked to this report. The corresponding amendment to the Fiscal Equalization Act will only take effect once the last federal state has submitted its report. (Source: Research Services of the German Bundestag, Parliamentary Groups 8 (Health, Family, Education and Research, Environment) and 4 (Budget and Finance) dated November 6, 2025, Ref. Nos. WD 8-3000-083/25, WD 4-3000-056/25, p. 11) Only then can the increased funds be made available. Although constitutional law does not allow any conditions to be attached to the distribution and use of sales tax, political will is nevertheless clarified and linked to it.
Time period from 2032
From 2032 onwards, the legal entitlement to benefits under the Violence Assistance Act will take effect, meaning that the federal states addressed by this law will now assume financial responsibility. The costs of a stay in a women's shelter will no longer be reimbursable by a municipal agency. The German Social Code, Book II (SGB II), will no longer apply.
Consequences for the financial responsibility of the federal government, states and municipalities
The obligation to provide sufficient protection facilities and counselling centers already arises from the Istanbul Convention, the recommendations from the GREVIO report and ultimately from the EU Directive on domestic violence.
Allocation of funds by the states
The Violence Assistance Act is directed at the federal states and imposes obligations on them to ensure access to the support system and its financing. However, the structure and phased timeline of the Act indicate that federal funds and the co-financing to be provided by the states are initially intended to prepare for the legal entitlement under Section 3 of the Violence Assistance Act. While the "ongoing operation" can, in principle, also be financed with these funds (see the explanatory memorandum in the recommendation for a resolution and the report of the Committee on Family Affairs, Senior Citizens, Women and Youth of January 29, 2025; Bundestag printed matter 20/14785, p. 14), this appears unrealistic given the considerable requirements for expansion and the associated costs.
The Cost study The Federal Ministry for Family Affairs, Senior Citizens, Women and Youth assumes an annual financing cost for the entire support system of between €687,8 million (Scenario 2) and €1,646 billion (Scenario 1), depending on the scenario.
The Fiscal Equalization Act stipulates the following distribution of value-added tax revenue for all federal states, which is yet to be allocated: €112.000.000 in 2027, €141.500.002 in 2028, €191.540.000 in 2029, and €306.499.997 annually from 2030 onwards. This already makes it clear that even with the lower end of the funding scale (Scenario 2), these funds would not even cover day-to-day operations. If they were used for that purpose, nothing would be left for the desired expansion and development.
The gradually implemented responsibility for ensuring support and the preparation of the legal claim arise from the wording in Section 5 Paragraph 1 of the Trade and Commerce Act (GewHG) "to guarantee the claims under Section 3." The explanatory memorandum to the law also assumes that the support system is to be established gradually, and that federal financial support is intended to serve this purpose. (Draft of a law for a reliable support system for gender-based and domestic violence of December 3, 2024, Bundestag printed matter 20/14025, p. 39)
A direct obligation for the states to use federal funds for the expansion or ongoing operation of the aid system cannot be constitutionally justified, as the distribution of value-added tax revenue is inherently unconditional. It is impossible to predict to what extent a completely misuse of funds would be sanctioned – through a formal complaint – as nothing comparable has yet occurred in the Federal Republic of Germany.
In summary, it can be stated that the federal states will only be obligated to fulfill the requirements of the Violence Assistance Act from 2032 onwards.
Consequences for municipal funding
Municipalities and cities currently provide protection and counselling services based on the German Social Code, Book II (SGB II, Section 16a – psychosocial support – and Section 22 SGB II – costs of accommodation and heating) and Book XII (SGB XII, Sections 67 et seq., 27, 41 et seq. SGB XII). These are mandatory municipal services. As the responsible service provider, municipalities remain subject to the obligation to ensure these services under Section 17, Paragraph 1, Numbers 1 and 2 of the German Social Code, Book I (SGB I). This does not initially entail mandatory funding for women's shelters and specialized counselling centers. Any such funding constitutes a voluntary service.
On the other hand, municipalities are subject to a constitutional guarantee of self-government, from which obligations for the local community also derive. (Janda: Protection against violence as a municipal task? In DÖV 2023, p. 10) Thus, as service providers, they are obligated to provide sufficient services for the realization of statutory (social) benefits. To this end, they can utilize non-governmental providers, which they equip with the necessary resources. This is governed by fee or remuneration agreements.
According to Article 2 of the Law for a Reliable Support System for Gender-Based and Domestic Violence, the reimbursement of municipal services for stays in women's shelters will explicitly cease from 2032 onwards. At the same time, the legal entitlement under Section 3 of the German Act on the Protection of Women (GewHG) will come into effect. Until then, however, the principles outlined above remain in force. This means that a withdrawal of municipal funding is not currently possible.
If voluntary contributions or subsidies to women's shelters or specialist counseling centers are discontinued, the mandatory social welfare services must be financed differently. Since these institutions are used to fulfill the aforementioned obligations, they still require adequate funding. If contributions are reduced or discontinued, adjustments to reimbursement rates are necessary. This requires amending or renegotiating service agreements.
Action options for the support system
If a benefit is discontinued, new or amended benefit and remuneration agreements must be requested and negotiated. Strict requirements apply under the German Social Code, Book XII (SGB XII), for which legal counsel is recommended. If negotiations fail, the responsible arbitration board should be contacted.
The German Social Code, Book II (SGB II), contains few explicit legal regulations. However, it is possible to request an adjustment of existing remuneration agreements or the initial conclusion of benefit agreements. If this cannot be achieved, a general claim for benefits must be filed with the social court.